Skip to Content

What to Do if Your Etsy Package is Stolen

What to Do if Your Etsy Package is Stolen

If you’ve ever had an Etsy package stolen, you know how frustrating and disappointing it can be. Whether it’s a one-of-a-kind handmade item or a special gift for a loved one, losing a package can feel like a huge loss. Fortunately, there are steps you can take to try and recover your stolen package or get a refund for your purchase.

First, it’s important to contact the seller and let them know what happened. They may be able to offer you a replacement or a refund, depending on their policies. You can also file a claim with the shipping carrier, such as USPS, UPS, or FedEx, to see if they can help locate your package or provide compensation for the loss. Additionally, you can file a police report if you believe the package was stolen from your property.

Overall, it’s important to act quickly and take all necessary steps to try and recover your stolen package. While there’s no guarantee that you’ll be able to get it back, taking action can help increase your chances of success.

Understanding Etsy’s Policies

Seller Responsibility

As a seller on Etsy, it is your responsibility to ensure that your packages are delivered to the buyer safely. You should use a reliable shipping service and provide tracking information to the buyer. It is also important to pack the item securely to avoid any damage during transit. If the package is lost or stolen during transit, you should file an insurance claim with the shipping carrier and provide a replacement or refund to the buyer.

Buyer Protection

Etsy offers buyer protection for purchases made on the platform. If the item does not arrive, arrives damaged, or does not match the item description or photos, the buyer can open a case with Etsy. For qualifying orders, the buyer will receive a refund for the item. It is important to keep the transaction on Etsy, as Etsy cannot verify or assist with payments made outside of the platform.

It is important to note that Etsy has policies in place to protect both buyers and sellers. It is important to familiarize yourself with these policies to ensure a smooth transaction. Etsy’s policies can be found in their House Rules, which include criteria for handmade, vintage, and craft supply items, prohibited items, and expectations for customer service.

Steps to Take if Your Etsy Package is Stolen

If you find out that your Etsy package has been stolen, don’t panic. There are steps you can take to try and recover your package or receive a refund. Here are some suggested steps to take:

Contact the Seller

The first thing to do is to contact the seller. Let them know that your package was stolen and ask if they can help you in any way. They may be able to offer a refund or send a replacement package. Make sure to provide them with any relevant information, such as the tracking number and the date the package was supposed to arrive.

File a Police Report

If you believe that your package was stolen, it’s important to file a police report. This will help to create a record of the theft and may help to prevent future thefts. Contact your local police department and provide them with any information you have about the theft, such as the date and time it occurred and any witnesses you may have.

Contact Your Local Postal Service

Contact your local postal service and let them know that your package has been stolen. They may be able to provide you with more information about the theft and may be able to help you recover your package. Also, ask if they have any policies or procedures in place for dealing with stolen packages.

Remember, it’s important to act quickly if you believe your package has been stolen. By taking these steps, you may be able to recover your package or receive a refund.

Preventing Package Theft

Delivery Instructions

One way to prevent package theft is to provide specific delivery instructions to the carrier. For example, you can ask the carrier to leave the package at a specific location, such as a back door or a porch out of sight. You can also ask the carrier to require a signature upon delivery, which can ensure that packages are not left unattended.

Security Cameras

Installing security cameras can also deter package theft. Cameras can be placed at the front door or other areas where packages are delivered. In the event that a package is stolen, the footage can be used as evidence to help identify the thief.

Package Lockers

Another option is to use package lockers. Many apartment complexes and communities offer package lockers as a secure way to receive deliveries. These lockers are usually located in a central area and require a code or key to access. This ensures that packages are not left unattended and are only accessible to the intended recipient.

By implementing these measures, you can help prevent package theft and ensure that your Etsy purchases arrive safely and securely.

Insurance and Claims

If your Etsy package is stolen, you may be able to file an insurance claim. Here are some things you should know about insurance and claims for shipping labels:

Filing a Claim

If your package was insured, you can file a claim for the value of the item(s) and the cost of shipping. To file a claim, follow these steps:

  1. On, go to You > Shop Manager.
  2. Go to Orders & Shipping.
  3. Click the order with the insured label.
  4. Click the … icon to the right.
  5. Select File Insurance Claim.
  6. You’ll be directed to the Shipsurance website to fill out the remainder of your claim form.

Package Insurance

When you purchase shipping labels on Etsy, you have the option to add insurance or coverage for your package. Some shipping methods come with insurance included. To purchase insurance for shipping labels:

  1. Follow the steps to purchase a shipping label.
  2. Under “Insurance,” select the amount of coverage you want.
  3. Review the cost of the insurance and click “Confirm and Pay.”

Note that not all shipping methods are eligible for insurance, and some countries may have restrictions on insurance coverage. Be sure to check the shipping carrier’s website for more information.

Remember, insurance is not a guarantee that you will be reimbursed for lost or stolen packages. Be sure to take other precautions, such as using a secure delivery address and requiring signature confirmation, to help prevent theft.

Alternative Solutions

If you are concerned about package theft in your area, there are a few alternative solutions that you can consider to ensure that your Etsy package arrives safely.

Pick Up in Person

One option is to arrange to pick up your package in person from the seller. This is a great solution if you live nearby or are willing to make the trip. You can contact the seller through Etsy and ask if they offer local pick-up options. If they do, you can arrange a time and place to meet and pick up your package. This way, you can ensure that your package arrives safely in your hands.

Delivery to Work Address

Another option is to have your package delivered to your work address. This is a great solution if you work in a secure building or office. You can provide the seller with your work address and ask them to send your package there instead of your home address. This way, you can ensure that your package is delivered to a secure location and that it will be safe until you can pick it up.

Remember, if your package is stolen, there are steps you can take to try and recover it. But prevention is always the best solution. By taking steps to protect your packages, you can reduce the risk of package theft and ensure that your Etsy purchases arrive safely.