Skip to Content

Etsy vs. Madeit

Etsy vs. Madeit

Etsy and Madeit are two popular online marketplaces that offer a platform for artisans to sell their handmade goods. Both platforms provide a wide range of unique and creative items that are not commonly found in traditional stores. Although they share some similarities, they also have some key differences that set them apart from each other.

One of the main differences between Etsy and Madeit is their geographic focus. While Etsy is a global platform that attracts buyers and sellers from all over the world, Madeit is an Australian-based marketplace that primarily caters to the Australian market. This means that Madeit sellers have a better chance of reaching local buyers, while Etsy sellers have access to a much larger customer base.

Another difference between the two platforms is their fee structure. Etsy charges a listing fee, a transaction fee, and a payment processing fee, while Madeit charges a flat monthly fee. This means that Madeit sellers may have lower overhead costs, but Etsy sellers may have access to more features and tools to help them grow their business. Ultimately, the choice between Etsy and Madeit will depend on the seller’s personal preferences and business goals.

Overview of Etsy

Etsy is a popular e-commerce platform that focuses on handmade and vintage items, as well as craft supplies. It was founded in 2005 by Rob Kalin, Chris Maguire, and Haim Schoppik, and has since grown to become a global marketplace with over 4 million active sellers and 90 million active buyers.

One of the unique features of Etsy is that it allows sellers to open their own online shops within the platform. This gives sellers the ability to customize their shop’s branding and layout, as well as to communicate directly with buyers through features like the shop announcement and private messaging.

In addition to its main marketplace, Etsy also offers a number of other features and services to help sellers grow their businesses. These include Etsy Ads, which allow sellers to promote their listings across the platform, as well as Etsy Payments, which provides a secure and streamlined payment processing system.

Overall, Etsy is a great platform for anyone looking to sell handmade or vintage items, or craft supplies. Its large and engaged community of buyers and sellers, combined with its user-friendly interface and powerful features, make it a top choice for many online sellers.

Related Posts:

Overview of Madeit

Madeit is an online marketplace for handmade goods based in Australia. It was founded in 2009 by two sisters who were passionate about supporting local artisans and makers. The platform has since grown to become a popular destination for Australian buyers and sellers of handmade items.

One of the unique features of Madeit is that it only allows sellers from within Australia. This means that buyers can be assured that they are supporting local makers and artisans. The platform is also more ban happy than Etsy, which means that it takes a strong stance against counterfeit or mass-produced items. This helps to maintain the integrity of the platform and ensures that buyers are getting high-quality, handmade goods.

Madeit offers a wide range of categories for sellers to list their items, including art, jewellery, homewares, and clothing. The platform also offers a range of tools and resources to help sellers build their businesses, such as marketing tips and advice on pricing their items. Overall, Madeit is a great option for buyers and sellers who are passionate about supporting local makers and artisans in Australia.

Business Model Comparison

Revenue Generation

Both Etsy and Madeit generate revenue by charging sellers a listing fee when they add an item to their marketplace. Etsy charges $0.20 for each item listed, while Madeit charges $0.25. Additionally, Etsy charges a transaction fee of 5% on the sale price of each item, while Madeit charges a 6% commission on the sale price.

Seller Support

Etsy offers a variety of tools and resources to help sellers succeed, including a Seller Handbook, a community forum, and personalized support from Etsy staff. Madeit also offers a seller handbook and community forum, but their support is more limited.

Buyer Protection

Both Etsy and Madeit have measures in place to protect buyers, such as a review system and a case resolution process. However, Etsy has a more robust buyer protection policy, including a money-back guarantee and an extensive dispute resolution process.

Related Posts:

Product Range and Quality

Etsy’s Product Diversity

Etsy is well-known for its diverse range of products, which includes handmade, vintage, and unique items. With over 4 million active sellers and 90 million active buyers, Etsy is a popular platform for finding one-of-a-kind products. In terms of product quality, Etsy has a strict policy that requires sellers to provide accurate descriptions and high-quality photos of their products.

Etsy’s product range includes a wide variety of categories such as clothing, jewelry, home decor, art, and craft supplies. The platform also offers customization options, allowing buyers to personalize their purchases. For example, sellers can offer custom sizes, colors, or even engraving services.

Madeit’s Unique Offerings

Madeit is an Australian-owned online marketplace that focuses on handmade goods. Unlike Etsy, Madeit does not allow third-party manufactured products, ensuring that all items sold on the platform are handmade. Madeit has a smaller seller and buyer base than Etsy, but it offers unique products that are not available on other platforms.

Madeit’s product range includes handmade clothing, jewelry, home decor, and art. The platform also has a section for eco-friendly and sustainable products, reflecting the growing trend towards environmentally-conscious consumerism. Madeit supports local artists and makers, making it a great platform for discovering unique and locally-made products.

Related Posts:

User Experience Comparison

Website Navigation

Etsy and Madeit both have user-friendly websites that are easy to navigate. However, Etsy has a more polished and professional look, with a layout that is more aesthetically pleasing. Madeit’s website, on the other hand, appears to be more basic and simple.

Etsy’s website has a search bar that makes it easy for users to find specific items, and its filters make it easy to narrow down search results. Madeit’s search function is also effective, but its filters are not as comprehensive as Etsy’s.

Mobile App Usability

Both Etsy and Madeit have mobile apps that allow users to shop on the go. Etsy’s app is more popular and has a higher rating on both the App Store and Google Play. The app is easy to use and has all the same features as the website, including the ability to search for items, make purchases, and leave reviews.

Madeit’s app, while functional, is not as popular as Etsy’s and has some limitations. For example, users cannot create listings on the app and must use the website instead.

Customer Reviews

Both Etsy and Madeit allow customers to leave reviews on their purchases. Etsy’s review system is more robust and allows users to rate their purchases on a scale of 1-5 stars and leave written feedback. Madeit’s review system is simpler and only allows users to leave a written review.

Overall, Etsy has a more polished and professional user experience than Madeit, with a more comprehensive search function and a more popular mobile app. However, Madeit’s website is still easy to use and its review system is effective.

Related Posts:

Seller Experience Comparison

Setting Up Shop

Setting up a shop on both Etsy and Madeit is relatively easy and straightforward. Both platforms require sellers to create an account and provide basic information such as their name, shop name, and payment details. However, Etsy has a more extensive onboarding process that includes a detailed guide on how to set up a shop, while Madeit has a simpler process.

Etsy provides more customization options for shop owners, including the ability to add a banner, shop icon, and shop policies. Madeit, on the other hand, has a more minimalist design with fewer customization options.

Sales and Marketing Support

Both platforms offer sales and marketing support to their sellers. Etsy provides a variety of tools to help sellers promote their products, including the ability to create sales and coupon codes, run promoted listings, and use Etsy’s search analytics tool to optimize listings. Madeit, on the other hand, has fewer marketing tools and relies more on organic search traffic.

Etsy also offers a robust shipping and order management system, which includes the ability to print shipping labels directly from the platform. Madeit does not have a built-in shipping system, so sellers must handle shipping and order management themselves.

Community Interaction

Etsy has a larger and more active community than Madeit, with millions of buyers and sellers worldwide. Etsy’s community includes forums, teams, and social media groups where sellers can connect with each other and share tips and advice. Madeit has a smaller community, but it is still active and supportive.

Both platforms have a review system that allows buyers to leave feedback on their purchases. However, Etsy’s review system is more visible and influential, as it appears prominently on each listing and can affect a seller’s search ranking. Madeit’s review system is less visible and does not have as much impact on a seller’s performance.

Related Posts: