Skip to Content

What Gets 5 Star Reviews on Etsy?

What Gets 5 Star Reviews on Etsy?

Are you an Etsy seller looking to improve your ratings? Getting 5-star reviews on Etsy is essential to the success of your shop. But what makes a product worthy of a perfect rating? According to an analysis of reviews on Etsy, shoppers often mention how much they “love” the items they purchased and how “perfect” the items are for them.

While it may seem like a daunting task to consistently receive top ratings, there are steps you can take to increase your chances. Paying attention to the quality of your products, providing excellent customer service, and promptly addressing any issues that arise can all contribute to positive reviews. Keep reading for more tips on how to get 5-star reviews on Etsy.

Related Posts:

Understanding Etsy’s Rating System

Importance of 5 Star Reviews

As an Etsy seller, it’s important to understand the significance of 5-star reviews. These reviews are crucial for building trust with potential customers and can greatly impact your shop’s success. Etsy’s rating system is based on a 5-star scale, with 5 being the highest rating. The goal for sellers is to maintain a 95%+ rating of 5 stars to earn the coveted Star Seller badge.

How Ratings are Calculated

Etsy calculates your 5-star rating percentage by dividing the number of reviews that have 5 stars by the total number of ratings you’ve received during the calculation period. Other reviews, such as those with 4 stars, are not considered. Buyers have 100 days to review an order, beginning on the delivery date or estimated delivery date.

It’s important to note that Etsy’s rating system is not perfect and there have been concerns about fake reviews and inflated ratings. However, as a seller, it’s important to focus on providing excellent customer service and high-quality products to earn genuine 5-star reviews.

Related Posts:

Key Elements of 5 Star Products

To receive 5-star reviews on Etsy, it’s important to focus on the key elements that make a product stand out. These elements include unique design, quality of materials, and craftsmanship.

Unique Design

A unique design is what sets a product apart from the competition. It’s important to create a design that is both eye-catching and functional. Consider incorporating unique colors, patterns, and textures that will appeal to your target audience. Additionally, make sure your design is easy to understand and use.

Quality of Materials

The quality of materials used in a product is an important factor in receiving 5-star reviews. Make sure to source high-quality materials that are durable and long-lasting. This will not only increase customer satisfaction but also help to build a positive reputation for your brand.


Craftsmanship is the attention to detail and care put into creating a product. It’s important to take the time to create a product that is well-made and free from defects. This will show customers that you care about the quality of your product and their satisfaction.

Related Posts:

Exceptional Customer Service

Providing exceptional customer service is key to receiving 5-star reviews on Etsy. This means going above and beyond to make sure your customers are satisfied with their experience. Here are some ways you can provide exceptional customer service:

Communication with Buyers

Communication is key when it comes to customer service. Make sure to respond to messages from buyers in a timely and friendly manner. Answer any questions they may have about your products or policies. Keep them updated on the status of their order, including when it has shipped and when they can expect to receive it.

Shipping and Delivery

Shipping and delivery are important parts of the customer experience. Make sure to ship orders promptly and provide tracking information so buyers can keep track of their package. Use high-quality packaging materials to ensure that products arrive in good condition. If there are any issues with the delivery, work with the buyer to resolve them as quickly as possible.

Related Posts:

Effective Product Presentation

To get 5-star reviews on Etsy, effective product presentation is key. This includes high-quality product photography and detailed product descriptions.

Product Photography

Product photography is the first thing potential customers see when browsing your Etsy shop. It’s important to have clear, well-lit photos that showcase your products from different angles. Consider using a plain background and natural lighting to make your products stand out.

You can also use props or models to show your products in use and give customers a better idea of how they look in real life. Make sure your photos are high-resolution and show the details of your products.

Product Descriptions

Product descriptions should be detailed and accurate. They should include important information like materials, dimensions, and care instructions. Use descriptive language to highlight the unique features of your products and make them stand out from the competition.

Consider using bullet points or tables to make important information easy to find. Use keywords and phrases that potential customers might search for to improve your visibility in Etsy search results.

Related Posts:

Building Trust with Buyers

Establishing a Strong Brand

One of the most important things you can do to build trust with buyers on Etsy is to establish a strong brand. This means creating a cohesive, professional-looking shop with a Shop Icon, Shop Owner photo, and visually similar imagery. According to Etsy’s research, buyers feel more confident purchasing from sellers who have been thoughtful about their shops’ branding.

Make sure your branding is consistent across all your listings, social media profiles, and any other online presence you have. This will help buyers recognize your brand and feel more comfortable purchasing from you.

Collecting Positive Reviews

Positive reviews are crucial to building trust with buyers on Etsy. Make sure to provide excellent customer service and high-quality products to encourage buyers to leave positive reviews. You can also follow up with customers after their purchase to ask for a review.

Responding to reviews, both positive and negative, is also important. Thank buyers for their positive reviews and address any concerns or issues raised in negative reviews.

Collecting positive reviews can take time, but it’s worth the effort. Positive reviews will help build your credibility as a seller and encourage new buyers to purchase from you.

Related Posts:

Leveraging Social Media and SEO

Promoting on Social Media

One effective way to get 5-star reviews on Etsy is to promote your shop on social media platforms like Pinterest, Instagram, and Facebook. By sharing your products and shop updates on these platforms, you can attract more potential customers to your shop and increase your chances of getting positive reviews.

Pinterest is a great platform for promoting Etsy products because it allows users to save and share images, making it easy to showcase your products and drive traffic to your shop. Instagram is another popular platform for Etsy sellers, with features like hashtags and stories that can help you reach a wider audience. Facebook is also a useful platform for promoting Etsy products, with options like Facebook ads and groups that can help you target specific audiences.

Optimizing for Search

Another way to increase your chances of getting 5-star reviews on Etsy is to optimize your shop for search engines. This involves using relevant keywords in your product titles, descriptions, and tags to help your products appear higher in search results. You can also optimize your shop by using high-quality images, providing detailed product descriptions, and offering excellent customer service.

To optimize your shop for search, you can use tools like eRank and Marmalead, which provide insights into popular keywords and help you track your shop’s performance. You can also conduct your own keyword research by looking at popular search terms on Etsy and using them in your product listings.

Related Posts: